Hay Sweetie Review

Dec 24, 2020
𝙰 πš•πš˜πš˜πš” πš‹πšŠπšŒπš” 𝚊𝚝 π™·πšŠπš’πšœπš πšŽπšŽπšπš’πšŽβ€™πšœ πš‡πš–πšŠπšœ πš–πšŽπš—πšž! πŸŽ„

πŸͺ π‚πšπ§ππ² π‚πšπ§πž π‹πšπ§πž
β€’ 6.2 oz
β€’ππšπ¬πž: White chocolate
β€’πŒπ’π±-𝐒𝐧𝐬: Christmas Oreos + white chocolate chips + white chocolate peppermint Kisses
‒𝐅𝐒π₯π₯𝐒𝐧𝐠: Peppermint milk chocolate buttercream
‒𝐓𝐨𝐩𝐩𝐒𝐧𝐠: White chocolate + candy cane bits
➑️ I’ve been all about peppermint this month!❀️ It has a soft base with a good flavor to it. It didn’t taste specifically like white chocolate to me, but I feel like that’s a tricky base flavor to make stand out. I LOVED the filling! It was flavorful, yet light and fluffy. It was the perfect balance of chocolate vs peppermint. I found that it was not a very rich cookie, so it’s easy to eat the whole thing! My boyfriend loved it too! 9.2/10

πŸͺ π“π‘πž 𝐏𝐞𝐫𝐟𝐞𝐜𝐭 𝐌𝐚𝐧 𝐒𝐬 𝐚 π†π’π§π πžπ«
β€’ 6.6 oz
β€’ππšπ¬πž: Spiced gingerbread
β€’πŒπ’π±-𝐒𝐧𝐬: Ginger snaps + cinnamon chips
‒𝐅𝐒π₯π₯𝐒𝐧𝐠: Cookie butter
‒𝐓𝐨𝐩𝐩𝐒𝐧𝐠: Rolled in sugar dust + a cookie butter filled ginger snap
➑️ Wow! If you’ve followed me for a bit, you know I love spice and that gingerbread is my weakness πŸ™Œ The dough is soft and flavorful! There’s plenty of spice without being overwhelming. Having cookie butter in the center is just the perfect touch. I ate mine at room temp, but it would be even better warmed up! ⚠️ Warning: product is highly addictive 9.8/10 ⭐️ 𝔾.𝕆.𝔸.𝕋.


πŸͺ π’πšπ§π­πšβ€™π¬ 𝐊𝐒π₯𝐨
β€’ 8.4 oz
β€’ππšπ¬πž: Sugar cookie
β€’πŒπ’π±-𝐒𝐧𝐬: White chocolate chips + sprinkles + Little Debbie Christmas tree cakes
‒𝐅𝐒π₯π₯𝐒𝐧𝐠: Frosting
‒𝐓𝐨𝐩𝐩𝐒𝐧𝐠: Edible sugar cookie dough + white chocolate + edible glitter
➑️ Sugar cookies are a staple for the holidays! The dough is soft and on the sweet side. It’s matched by an equally sweet filling and topping. It reminds me a little of the LoftHouse frosted cookies, but better! A pal from the gym @shortnswole said it’s not too sweet and he loves the filling because it tastes like birthday cake frosting! It’s such a fun glow up from the classic sugar cookie πŸ™Œ 9/10

πŸͺ π‚πšπ«πšπ¦πžπ₯ 𝐌𝐚𝐜𝐜𝐑𝐒𝐚𝐭𝐨
β€’7.3 oz
β€’ππšπ¬πž: Caramel w/ espresso
β€’πŒπ’π±-𝐒𝐧𝐬: Espresso chips + caramel bits
‒𝐅𝐒π₯π₯𝐒𝐧𝐠: Caramel buttercream
‒𝐓𝐨𝐩𝐩𝐒𝐧𝐠: Caramel + chocolate drizzle
➑️ I’m not a coffee person, so I wouldn’t have ordered this personally. Haysweetie gifted this (thank you!) and I’m so glad they did! The first word out of my mouth was β€œWow!” It has a sweet and very soft dough. The rich caramel flavor is complemented by the espresso. My worry was that the espresso would overpower everything, but it wasn’t too strong. Anyone, coffee lover or not, would love this cookie! 9.8/10 ⭐️ 𝔾.𝕆.𝔸.𝕋.


πŸͺ 𝐌𝐞𝐫𝐫𝐲 π‚π‘πžπ«π«π²
β€’7.6 oz
β€’ππšπ¬πž: Milk chocolate
β€’πŒπ’π±-𝐒𝐧𝐬: Dried cherries + dark chocolate chips
‒𝐅𝐒π₯π₯𝐒𝐧𝐠: Cherry cordial
‒𝐓𝐨𝐩𝐩𝐒𝐧𝐠: Cherry buttercream + brownie bite + milk chocolate + edible glitter
➑️ This one was a great surprise for me! I don’t usually care for cherries, but they sure know how to make a good cookie! It has a soft, sweet, and fudgey base. It reminded me a bit of a brownie πŸ˜‹ The brownie on top was sweet and so was the tasty cherry buttercream! I would love to see this cookie on the Valentines menu (Hint hint wink wink πŸ˜‰) 9.5/10

πŸͺ 𝐌𝐚𝐩π₯𝐞 π‚πšπ§ππ’πžπ 𝐏𝐞𝐜𝐚𝐧𝐬
β€’4.5 oz
➑️ This is an extra they gifted me with my order πŸ’• They were sweet and delicious! The maple flavor came through well without being overpowering. Overall, these were addictive and the perfect snack 🀀



πŸͺ𝐏𝐫𝐒𝐜𝐞: $5.50 for the pecans. $6-$6.50 for the cookies I featured. $15 shipping.
π™Ώπšžπš›πšŒπš‘πšŠπšœπšŽπš + π™Άπš’πšπšπšŽπš
πŸͺ𝐎𝐫𝐝𝐞𝐫𝐒𝐧𝐠: Some of the flavors are available now on their website.
πŸͺ𝐎𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐚π₯π₯ π‘πšπ­π’π§π : πŸ—.πŸ“β€“π™²π™Ύπ™Ύπ™Ίπ™Έπ™΄ π™²π™Ύπš„π™½πšƒπ™΄πš π™°π™Ώπ™Ώπšπ™Ύπš…π™΄π™³βœ…

β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”

April 10, 2020
Haysweetie, based out of Indiana, was started by Hayley (Hay). While prepping for one of her bikini competitions, she couldn’t find a cookie that was soft and moist without having to heat it up post-show. That’s when she created her own perfect cookie. It became such a hit that her friends kept asking to buy more and so she opened up shop. She works part-time as a registered nurse, so her fiancΓ©, Josh, got involved after finishing college. She calls him her dough-it-all boy and they plan to make this a family business.
β €
All of the cookies are soft and definitely don’t need to be warmed up to enjoy! Thank you @haysweetie for adding two cookies to my pack!
πŸ”ΉNot Yo Average BJ (7.6 oz)- Inspired by Ben & Jerry’s Half-Baked ice cream. Brownie batter base w/ cookie dough bits, PB chips, and white chocolate chips mixed in. Marshmallow fluff center. PB on top. Top layer of PB cookie dough w/ white choc chips, Reese’s cups, and Reese’s pieces. All coated with white chocolate.😡 This cookie was massive and smelled amazing! The cookie was a fun creation and very good! All of it’s components are very sweet, so I would have liked the brownie base to be more rich/fudgey to balance out the sweetness. 8.5/10


πŸ”ΉNot Your Grandma’s Oatmeal Cookie (5.5 oz)- Cinnamon oatmeal base w/ cinnamon chips and white chocolate chips mixed in. Filled with vanilla marshmallow frosting and topped with an oatmeal cream pie. Holy spice! This cookie was NOT dry (oatmeal cookies can sometimes be). The filling was delicious and balanced out how well spiced the base is. Now THIS is how you do an oatmeal cookie everyone! πŸ‘ 10/10 and has made it’s way onto my G.O.A.T list! πŸ”₯


πŸ”ΉThe OG (5.4 oz)- *This chocolate chip cookie has four different types of chocolate chips and a brownie batter filling.*The cookie was very chewy with a neutral flavored dough. Although I prefer a more flavorful dough, the mix-ins offered a lot of flavor to the cookie. This is the most fun C.C. cookie I’ve come across! 7/10


πŸ”ΉSalty B (5.6 oz)- *Salted caramel base w/ salted caramel chips, milk choc chips, chocolate covered pretzels, and pecans mixed in. Filled with cookie butter and a chocolate pretzel on top.* It has a strong and tasty caramel base. The pretzels inside were stale (common with pretzels in any company’s cookie), but the pretzel on top was fresh. I did not get a strong salt flavor and feel like extra sea salt in the dough or sprinkled on top would be amazing. 7.5/10


πŸ”ΉBunny Trail (5.8 oz)- (This was a freebie from them. Thank you!) *Listed as an oatmeal carrot cake base with raisins, white choc chips, and pecans mixed in. It has a cream cheese filling and topped with a carrot cake Oreo.* I loved the spiced oatmeal base, but I did not read the description of the cookie first and could not tell that it was a carrot cake base. The cream cheese was delicious! 7.5/10


πŸ”ΉCirque-de-licious (6 oz)- *White chocolate cake batter base with white choc chips, frosted circus cookies, and sprinkles mixed in. Filled with vanilla frosting and dipped in white chocolate.* Wow. This cookie blew my mind! Think of the vanilla cake at a B-day party and that is this cookie. Absolutely amazing. I wouldn’t change a thing. This is being added to my G.O.A.T list! 10/10πŸ™Œ

Overall, they succeeded in making cookies that are uniquely chewy and do NOT need to be microwaved to be enjoyed. She has fun flavors and, although there were some that weren’t favorites, two were INCREDIBLE and made it onto my G.O.A.T list! I plan to try out more of her cookies in the future!


πŸ”ΈPrice: $5/regular cookie and $7.50/specialty cookie. Shipping was $15.
πŸ”ΈOrdering: Orders seem to always be open, but cookies do sell out due sell out. My order was received 10 days after it was placed. Ships to Canada!
πŸ”ΈOverall Rating: 8.5/10πŸ”₯
β €

Leave a comment