Stuffed Cookies Review

April 26, 2020


Jenn’s journey into the cookie business started in culinary school. As a school project, she had to come up with a business plan. Her professor was so impressed that they encouraged her to pursue the venture. Stuffed Cookies was started in 2014 and has been successful ever since!

✨I was going to post tomorrow, but she has a few seasonal flavors that rotate each month. The current lineup is for just another 9 hours!✨
🍪Cinnamon Crumble Carrot Cake- 4.1 oz On the seasonal list. Cinnamon brown sugar base with carrots, cinnamon chips, and walnuts mixed in. Filled with cream cheese and topped with cinnamon crumbs. The dough for this cookie is delicious and spiced perfectly for the carrot cake theme! The walnuts are chopped up finely, so it blends into the dough well. The filling ties it all together. I ate the whole cookie! 9.8/10
🍪Cookie Butter Lemon Pie- 4.2 oz From the seasonal list, this is a lemon brown butter base w/ white chocolate chips mixed in. Filled with cookie butter and topped with Speculoos and lemon crumbs. I was surprised by how well the flavors worked together! The dough was a light lemon flavor. The cookie butter takes the show with this cookie and it just really works well! 8.5/10
🍪Sweet and Salty- 4.5 oz Vanilla brown butter base with chocolate chips, heath, salted caramel chips, Reese’s cups, and potato chips mixed in. Filled with Pb and topped with white chocolate and pretzels. This cookie has a whole lot going on! It has a tasty base with all the best snacks mixed in. The pretzels on top stayed fresh! It’s got just the right amount of salt to appeal to most people and it pairs well with all of the sweet aspects! 9.5/10

🍪Oreo Bday Cake- 4.5 oz Vanilla brown butter base with Oreos mixed in. Filled with cookie butter and topped with sprinkles. There was cookie butter in every bite, which is the strongest flavor in the cookie. It tasted like a spoonful of cookie butter, which I have zero complaints about 😂 The sprinkles give it a crunch with every bite! 8.8/10
🍪S’mores- 4.4 oz Vanilla brown butter base with chocolate chips and marshmallows mixed in. Filled with chocolate ganache and topped with graham crackers. I enjoyed the base and how the mix-ins worked well with it. Of course, the ganache filling was delicious! The graham crackers stayed fresh, which is a HUGE bonus! 8.8/10
🍪Nutella Chocolate Chunk- 4 oz Vanilla brown butter base with dark and milk chocolate chips mixed in. Filled with Nutella and topped with sea salt. Overall, a very good flavor. I mean, who DOESN’T love Nutella? I didn’t notice the salt on top, but that’s a minor thing. Good cookie! 8.8/10
🍪Red Velvet Cheesecake- Red velvet base with white chocolate chips mixed in. Filled with cream cheese frosting and topped with cinnamon graham cracker pieces. I’d say this is tied for best red velvet dough I’ve tasted so far. The filling is a very sweet cream cheese, which made the center nice and moist. The topping is pretty messy, so eat it over a plate! 9.5/10
🍪Salty Caramel White Chocolate Macadamia- I forgot to write down the weight 😅 Vanilla brown butter base with white chocolate chips and macadamia nuts mixed in. Filled with salted caramel and topped with sea salt. This one has a strong vanilla flavor and is pretty sweet, just like it should be! The salted caramel helps cut through the sweetness, making this a wonderful combo! I wouldn’t mind even more salt on top, but I think most people will think it’s the perfect amount as is. Loved their take on one of my childhood favorites! 9.5/10

🍪Slutty Cookie- 4 oz Vanilla and chocolate base with sea salt caramel chips mixed in. Filled with salted caramel, oreos, and chocolate ganache. The base has a sweet chocolate flavor on one side and then the vanilla side reminded me of vanilla ice cream in flavor. The caramel was stacked on top of the Oreo, which was my favorite bite! There’s just enough salt without being overpowering. 8.5/10
🍪Chocolate PB Dream- 4.6 oz Chocolate cookie with Reese’s pieces, chocolate chunks, and PB chips mixed in. Filled with chocolate ganache and PB and topped with sea salt. The dough is on the fudgey side and had a good flavor. I love sea salt in chocolate cookies because it cuts through the sweetness. The filling tasted great and tied everything together! 8.8/10


🍪Churro Y Horchata- 4 oz Cinnamon brown butter base filled with horchata cream cheese frosting and topped cinnamon sugar. I warmed it up and I can die happy now 🙌 As Forest Gump once said, “That’s all I have to say about that.” 9.8/10🔥



I was so impressed with this company from beginning to end! Their packaging is high quality and well thought out so that no cookies would get crushed during shipping. Have you looked at the pictures? They’re the most beautiful cookies I’ve seen! This would make a great gift for someone too. All of the cookies were delicious and that kind of consistency is what I look for!


🔹Price: $5.50/cookie. I ordered 7 and then they added 4 extra in for my review. Shipping is $5.99. The price of the cookie is slightly higher than average for the size, but the low shipping costs makes up for it. Add in the quality packaging and it seems like a fair price to me. 🙂
🔹Ordering: Allcookies were available every time I went on the website. My order shipped 6 days after placing it. The owner was adding to mine, so usually it’s a couple days sooner to ship out.
🔹Overall Rating: 9.5/10 –𝙲𝙾𝙾𝙺𝙸𝙴 𝙲𝙾𝚄𝙽𝚃𝙴𝚁 𝙰𝙿𝙿𝚁𝙾𝚅𝙴𝙳✅

Leave a comment