The Competitorβs Cookie Co Review
June 29, 2020
πͺππππππ« ππ¬ π πππ’π« π§- 12.5 oz Almond wedding cake base with vanilla bean and white chocolate chips mixed in. Filled with buttercream frosting and topped with pearls. Can we say GLAM?! It looks like it belongs at a Hollywood themed wedding! Iβve only been to one wedding in my adult life, so I donβt know what wedding cake tastes like. π€·π»ββοΈ(Can someone get married and invite me? Free cake and Iβm in!) I can tell you though that this base is amazing! Itβs soft and has a unique and intense flavor. Itβs not the same as eating a straight up almond, so donβt be worried by that. I donβt like almonds that much, but I loved this cookie! The frosting is delicious and very sweet, just like a cake would be. The taste of almond and frosting lingers for a few minutes afterward. Overall, highly addictive and it was the first cookie to be completely devoured by me! 9.8/10
πͺππ¨π§βπ ππ π πππ«ππ² ππ¨π¨π©ππ« π- 10.2 oz Funfetti sugar cookie base with golden birthday cake Oreos mixed in. Stuffed with cupcake Poptart and a sprinkle buttercream layer. Itβs a soft cookie with a slightly gooey bottom. The base is not very sweet like I had expected it to be, but still has that vanilla flavor. You can see the oreos and Poptart mixed in! The best bite is in the middle where you get a hint of the frosting. I would prefer a thicker layer of frosting in the cookie personally. Itβs ideal for people who like funfetti, but donβt enjoy the sugar overload that comes with cake. 8.5/10
πͺππ¨π«π§ ππ§π πππ’π¬ππ- 14.6 oz Peanut butter base with chocolate chips mixed in. Brownie center covered in peanut butter. Topped with a buckeye and chocolate drizzle.β’ I would have never thought to put a buckeye on a cookie. Genius! Itβs a rich and soft base with a hint of salt. The brownie center is also rich and contrasted by the sweet buckeye. I love a good chocolate and PB combo. Itβs rich. Itβs sweet. Itβs a dangerously good cookie! 9.5/10
πͺππ₯π₯ ππ ππ¨ π’π¬ ππ’π§, ππ’π§, ππ’π§- 9.5 oz Brown sugar base with Hersheyβs gold bars and potato chips mixed in. Topped with caramel drizzle and Himalayan sea salt.β’ As I bit down, I got a slightly crunchy outside and a gooey center. Thereβs a brown sugar taste, just as promised, with a hint of salt. The potato chips amp of the saltiness and you can see them in the base. She managed to keep them fresh too. Plenty of caramel in this cookie! It tastes great room temp, but I wish I had heated it up now that I think of it! (I may have eaten the whole thing already) If only I had a do-over π© 9.2/10
β
πͺPrice: $8.25 per cookie. Thatβs a GREAT deal for the size of the cookies!
β¨Mention βMayaβ to get a free cookie!β¨
πͺOrdering: Orders open tomorrow and youβll get the cookies in August. Order through DM.
πͺOverall Rating: 9.3/10 βπ²πΎπΎπΊπΈπ΄ π²πΎππ½ππ΄π π°πΏπΏππΎπ
π΄π³β
May 29, 2020
πͺπππ² πππ¬πβ’ Coconut key lime dough with pie crust and white chocolate chips mixed in. Filled with key lime pie and whipped cream. Topped with lime zest.β’ Loved this cookie! It had a very strong lime dough. I couldnβt really taste the coconut, but the texture of it came through in every bite. If you donβt like coconut, youβll still like this cookie. The whipped cream and the crust helped balance out the tang of the lime. I loved the crust mixed in and the filling was delicious! 9.5/10
πͺπ πππππ‘ ππππ π’π§ ππππ―ππ§β’Chocolate chip base with semi sweet chips, milk chocolate chips, cheesecake chunks, and walnuts mixed in. Filled with cheesecake, edible cookie dough, and walnuts.β’Itβs a pretty sweet cookie compared to other chocolate chip versions out there. It had the perfect amount of walnuts and the cheesecake really took center stage! The filling was sweetened just right. I didnβt notice edible cookie dough, but thatβs probably because the cookie itself is so soft to start with. If you like sweet cookies, give this one a try! 8.5/10
πͺπ
πππ₯π’π§β π
π¨π«π¦ππ₯β’Dark chocolate fudge base with chocolate cake and cheesecake mixed in. Filled with cheesecake, chocolate mousse, and vanilla mascarpone.β’ The fudgey dark chocolate base was so rich! The filling was also delicious. I warmed it up and it felt like I was actually eating The Cheesecake Factory π€€ Donβt try to eat the whole thing in one sitting. I may be a pro cookie eater, but I was defeated by this one.π I absolutely love dark chocolate and I thought this cookie was amazing! 10/10
May 5, 2020
As the name suggests, Erin is bikini competitor who got her start after hearing all the buzz around post-show treats. She had experience baking a lot for family and friends around the holidays and put it to good use. When sheβs not baking, she is a full-time special education teacher. After starting up last May, she has successfully marked herself as a hot post-show and every day cookie company!
πͺSundae Fundae- 9.3 oz Vanilla bean dough withwaffle cone and chocolate chips mixed in. Both stuffed and topped with hot fudge and sprinkles. I loved this cookie! It has a great vanilla base. I didnβt notice the waffle cone pieces, but that doesnβt bother me because they could have just been finely chopped up. Room temp or warmed, this cookie is amazing! It was my top cookie from the pack β€οΈ 9.8/10
πͺThe Floor is Lava...Cake! 9.4 oz Chocolate velvet fudge base with chocolate chips mixed in. Filled with chocolate hazelnut cream and topped with powdered sugar. Another great cookie! The base is a rich and fudgey flavor. The filling meltswhen you warm it up π€€ and luckily thereβs plenty of it. One of the top chocolate cookies Iβve had! 9.5/10
πͺMonster Cookie- 15.6 oz A soft sugar cookie with white chocolate chips and mini M&Ms mixed in. Filled with edible cookie dough and peanut butter. Wanted to disclose that Iβm not a huge sugar cookie fan, so this one wasnβt my favorite flavor out of the pack. Plenty of other people have tried it and thought it was great though. I was looking for more cookie dough and mix-ins. Erin said she will add more of those into the cookie for future batches. 7.8/10
πͺSouthern Belleπ- 12.1 oz Banana cookie base with white chocolate chips, pie crust, and Nilla wafers mixed in. Filled with pie crust and banana pudding. A gooey cookie with a dense dough. It has a strong banana pudding flavor! I didnβt notice chunks of crust and Nilla wafers, but they probably got softened by the gooey dough and blended in. The filling was delicious! If you love banana pudding, this is the cookie for you! She really nailed the flavor! I would eat this room temp or refrigerated. 9.8/10
β
Some great cookies in this lineup! Although the monster cookie wasnβt for me personally, the other three were home runs! I caught myself stealing bites of them throughout the day π Iβve also heard a lot of people say the strawberry shortcake cookie is really good!
πΉPrice: These were gifted to me. Priced at $8.25/cookie. Thatβs a great price for the size of the cookies! Shipping starts at $15.05.
β¨ Mention Maya @maya_ifbbpro when you order for a FREE cookie!β¨
πΉOrdering: She opens orders once a month with a new lineup each month. Orders are placed through DM.
πΉOverall Rating: 9.5/10 βπ²πΎπΎπΊπΈπ΄ π²πΎππ½ππ΄π π°πΏπΏππΎπ
π΄π³β
Do you ship to Oklahoma